From 6/6/09 Tampa Tribune
SEMINOLE HEIGHTS - Expect no lawsuit, but cyber action is a possibility as the executive board of the Old Seminole Heights Neighborhood Association tries to lay claim to a Web domain name.
The domain name in question is www.oldseminoleheightsfoundation.org. Board members say it was stolen by founders of the nonprofit Seminole Heights Foundation who had access to insider information from a committee appointed to explore the association’s own charitable organization.
Foundation members include two past association presidents, Randy Baron and Susan Long, and current crime watch coordinator, Christie Hess. They have declined to comment on legal issues. A March news release proclaimed the foundation’s mission is to search out grants and resources for projects in all three Seminole Heights neighborhoods: Old Seminole, Southeast Seminole and South Seminole.
“The board decides what options, if any, it wants to pursue,” said lawyer Hunter Chamberlin, who represents Old Seminole Heights Neighborhood Association. “Personally I think we have a strong case partly because of the secrecy in which it was done.”
The alternative to a lawsuit would be arbitration with ICANN, Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers. The nonprofit is the administrative body overseeing the Web including the assignment of domain names. It has a worldwide network of arbitration panels.
That is the path the association’s board is considering, said President Jeff Harmon.
The conflict between the foundation and the association, among the city’s most politically savvy and wealthiest neighborhood organizations, was front and center at a packed general membership meeting last week. It had been a topic of discussion for weeks among mostly anonymous bloggers.
Nearly three hours after the meeting began, Harmon called for the foundation and association to move on.
“It stops tonight,” he said. “I’m exhausted. I don’t have anything left for negative discussions.”
But the association has a full plate of divisive issues: a flawed, contentious election in October; divisions over a local historical district in Hampton Terrace; a petition for Hampton Terrace to secede from the association; and now the dispute about the foundation and how it was born.
“I think this has gone further than it needs to on both sides,” said Greg Barnhill, who served on the association’s committee. “I personally think we should move forward because what we are doing is tearing apart 20 years of volunteer hours over someone getting a name.”
The board last month hired a law firm to send a letter demanding the foundation give up its name and a second purchased domain name, www.oldseminole heightsfoundation.org, and strongly suggested its founders resign from the association.
Legal fees for the Chamberlin/Patrick law firm are discounted, but the board would not release the hourly rate.
The board maintains its committee considered Seminole Heights Foundation and Old Seminole Heights Foundation for its proposed charitable organization. That committee included Baron, and Long attended at least one meeting.
Board members said they felt blindsided when the foundation issued its news release.
But the letter and the board’s lawsuit threat were out of bounds to some.
“It’s too small of a community to start doing this,” said Dirk Peters. “Why don’t you guys take a couple steps back?”
Others said the loss of a domain name happens to everyone. “At this point it’s done,” said Barbara Stokoe. “I don’t know what standing here beating each other up accomplishes. If it was our name we should have registered it as soon as we knew it was important.”
At Tuesday’s meeting, Long said the foundation wanted to revitalize and redevelop Seminole Heights with devices to slow neighborhood traffic, crosswalks, trash bins and benches. She invited residents to submit ideas for future projects.
Some said there was room for two charitable groups representing Seminole Heights’ interests. Others said the groups would compete for the same dollars and create name confusion.
Board members said they weren’t sure they could get over the betrayal. “It’s a trust issue,” said Doreen DiBona. “We’re going to have to move on but we really do want Old Seminole Heights Foundation name back. That’s the issue we have.”
Harmon said whatever happens, the board will continue work on its charitable organization.
Reporter Kathy Steele can be reached at (813) 259-7652.
http://centraltampa2.tbo.com/content/2009/may/06/st-domain-name-puts-heights-groups-at-odds/